Hardware wallets are often seen as the safest way to store Bitcoin. Unlike keeping your coins on a cryptocurrency exchange, a hardware wallet allows you to control your own private keys. That means you don’t have to trust a third party with your funds. But what happens when the wallet itself has a hidden flaw?
That is exactly what appears to have happened with Coldcard, one of the most respected hardware wallets in the Bitcoin community. A weakness in the way some devices generated recovery seeds went unnoticed for years. Now, attackers have allegedly exploited that flaw to steal more than $90 million worth of Bitcoin, leaving thousands of users wondering whether their wallets are still safe.
The incident is a reminder that even security products can contain critical software bugs and that no technology is completely free of risk.
A Hidden Weakness in Seed Generation
Thousands of Bitcoin users rely on Coldcard hardware wallets, manufactured by Coinkite, to protect their savings. Coldcard has long enjoyed a strong reputation among experienced Bitcoin users because of its focus on security and advanced features.
Unfortunately, a serious weakness appears to have existed in the way some wallets generated their recovery seeds.
A recovery seed, often called a seed phrase, is a list of words that acts as the master key to a Bitcoin wallet. Every private key and every Bitcoin address in the wallet is mathematically derived from that seed phrase.
Whoever knows the seed phrase has complete control over the wallet.
Because of that, generating a truly random seed is one of the most important steps in creating a secure wallet.
The Randomness Wasn’t Random Enough
The problem dates back to March 2021, when new firmware was released for certain Coldcard devices.
According to researchers, the software accidentally relied on a MicroPython pseudorandom number generator (PRNG) instead of the intended true random number generator (TRNG).
The difference is crucial.
A true random number generator uses unpredictable physical processes to create randomness. This makes the generated seed extremely difficult to guess.
A pseudorandom number generator, on the other hand, produces numbers using a mathematical algorithm. While these numbers may appear random, they ultimately follow predictable rules if enough information is known.
In this case, the bug dramatically reduced the amount of randomness used to generate wallet seeds.
Instead of the expected 128 bits of entropy, affected wallets generated only about 72 bits.
That may still sound like a large number, but in cryptography, every bit of entropy matters. Reducing the randomness by that much makes it vastly easier for attackers to search through possible seed combinations using modern computing power.
Why Nobody Noticed for Years
One of the most surprising aspects of the incident is that the bug remained hidden for several years.
Security reviews had already confirmed that the hardware contained a functioning true random number generator. However, reviewers focused on whether the hardware component existed, not whether the firmware was actually calling it correctly.
As a result, the software continued using the weaker pseudorandom generator without anyone realizing it.
This illustrates an important lesson in cybersecurity: secure hardware alone is not enough. The software must also use it correctly. A tiny programming mistake can completely undermine an otherwise secure design.
More Than $90 Million in Bitcoin Stolen
The consequences have been severe.
Researchers estimate that attackers emptied more than 4,500 Bitcoin addresses, stealing over $90 million worth of Bitcoin.
Interestingly, this was not a traditional hack.
The attackers did not break into Coldcard’s systems, install malware, or steal passwords.
Instead, they used computing power to generate likely seed phrases based on the reduced amount of randomness. Whenever one of those generated seeds matched a real wallet that still contained Bitcoin, they automatically gained access to the private keys and transferred the funds.
In other words, the attackers didn’t steal the keys, they were able to recreate them.
That makes this incident especially alarming because it targets one of the fundamental assumptions behind Bitcoin security: that private keys are practically impossible to guess when generated correctly.
Did Artificial Intelligence Play a Role?
According to Alex Thorn, Head of Research at Galaxy, artificial intelligence may have helped identify and exploit the weakness.
He suggested that AI-assisted tools could have accelerated the brute-force search for vulnerable seed phrases.
Coinkite has also stated that someone likely used AI to discover the underlying software bug.
Whether AI directly generated the seed phrases or primarily helped identify the vulnerability is still unclear. However, there is little doubt that modern AI models are becoming increasingly effective at analyzing software, finding hidden bugs, and identifying security flaws that humans may overlook.
As AI continues to improve, software developers will face growing pressure to identify and fix vulnerabilities before attackers do.
What Should Coldcard Users Do?
Coinkite is urging affected users to immediately generate a new wallet using updated firmware and transfer all Bitcoin to the newly created addresses.
Anyone who created a wallet during the period affected by the bug should carefully review the company’s guidance and consider moving their funds as soon as possible.
If there is any uncertainty about whether a wallet is affected, creating a fresh wallet and transferring the Bitcoin is generally the safest course of action.
Hardware Wallets Are Still Safer, But Not Risk-Free
Many Bitcoin investors choose hardware wallets because they eliminate counterparty risk.
When you keep Bitcoin on an exchange, you depend on that company to remain solvent, secure, and honest. History has shown that exchanges can fail, be hacked, or even misuse customer funds.
A hardware wallet removes that dependency because you hold your own private keys.
However, this incident demonstrates that self-custody introduces a different kind of risk.
Instead of trusting an exchange, you are placing your trust in the hardware manufacturer, the firmware developers, and the quality of the wallet’s security design.
If any part of that process fails, the consequences can be severe.
Why Multisignature Wallets Can Reduce Risk
One way experienced Bitcoin holders reduce this type of risk is by using a multisignature (multisig) wallet.
With a multisig setup, multiple independent private keys are required to approve a transaction. Those keys can be generated on different brands of hardware wallets from different manufacturers.
For example, a 2-of-3 multisig wallet might require approval from any two out of three hardware wallets before Bitcoin can be spent.
If one manufacturer suffers from a hidden vulnerability like the Coldcard incident, the attacker still cannot access the Bitcoin without compromising the other devices.
Although multisig requires more technical knowledge and careful setup, it significantly reduces the risk of relying on a single hardware wallet.
Self-Custody Isn’t for Everyone
Securely generating, storing, and protecting recovery seeds requires both technical understanding and personal responsibility.
Many Bitcoin enthusiasts are comfortable managing that responsibility themselves. Others are not.
For investors who are less experienced, or who are managing substantial amounts of money, there may be advantages to diversifying how assets are stored.
Some people spread their Bitcoin across multiple reputable exchanges to reduce platform-specific risk. Others choose regulated investment products such as spot Bitcoin ETFs, where professional custodians handle key management and security.
Neither approach is completely risk-free, but both illustrate an important principle: diversification doesn’t only apply to investments. It also applies to custody.
A Wake-Up Call for the Bitcoin Industry
The Coldcard incident is a powerful reminder that even products built specifically for security can contain hidden vulnerabilities.
It does not mean hardware wallets are unsafe. In fact, for many users they remain one of the most secure ways to store Bitcoin. But it does show that no solution is perfect.
Whether you choose a hardware wallet, a multisignature setup, an exchange, or a regulated ETF, understanding the risks is just as important as understanding the potential rewards.
Good security is rarely about finding one perfect solution. Instead, it’s about recognizing where the risks lie, spreading those risks where possible, and regularly reviewing whether your current setup still provides the level of protection you need.